I'm still relatively new to Arizona, but based on what I know about tanagers a winter appearance is not common. According to distribution maps in my field guides, Hepatic Tanager is the only regular winter tanager, with a range limited to the southeast Arizona 'sky islands'. While my location is fairly far south in Arizona, it is in the low desert in an area with little habitat diversity (aside from the young trees and shrubs planted in our small community). It's fairly distant from typical Hepatic habitat.


I was leaning towards identifying this as Hepatic due to bill proportion, head shape, the grayish auriculars, and the single-note call. This identification was confirmed by a number of experts on the BIRDWG05 forum. And in the mean time it has already made another appearance on Feb 1.